Friday, September 05, 2014

(TL)ea(cr)(hn)ing


(TL)ea(cr)(hn)ing


The title (TL)ea(cr)(hn)ing is by intention. Without rubbing much of our brain it spells out Teaching and Learning in a single line.

Teaching and Learning are two sides of the same coin. Someone not so famous said, can I learn without teaching and can I teach without learning. Guess you learn even more as you teach and you teach only when you learn.

Learn anytime, anywhere is the current trend with all those online courses being made available. Initially it was just the digitization of mortar courses and not it is using multimedia to stream the concept. People say that we have moved from a stance where it was bookish and limited to a few to a more open leaning system which is available to almost anyone and most of the times “free”.

I still believe in a Guru shishya kind of a setup, where a student served the guru and in return may be he was imparted knowledge. The amount of effort that a student put in, in some sense displayed the thirst for knowledge and when the knowledge was imparted it was absorbed in spirit and body. I wonder if the leaning that the students derived would be as intense or as absorbing if the knowledge was imparted the day the student joined the guru. Today the stance is you have information (not knowledge) on the platter, it is for you to absorb the knowledge, you absorb the quantum which is determined by your focus and need.

Information is available and not knowledge is a fact. The upside of this is you have so many sources of information – but to try and find the information that is backed by an expert is often not considered. Just imagine a learning material put up by a person on effective cooking who has never cooked! The other aspect of this is that when there are several choices you need to appropriately select and quench your thirst for knowledge. In the good old days it was the teacher who did that; she acted as the funnel; disseminating information appropriately. If you were a bright student probably the outlet of the funnel was larger else it was smaller. Today in the online learning this important aspect of funnel is missing.

The anytime anywhere extension of the knowledge learning has a problem in a very different dimension. Discipline. 0830 morning lecture means I need to be in the classroom at 0829 and I plan and be there. But the anytime anywhere makes you less disciplined. If not now I can learn later, may be after a delay of 30 minutes, 1 month, 1 year of never! But the aspect of discipline is definitely at risk. While there is a notion that online and non-mortar courses are free a fiercely detailed person would immediately suggest that there is a cost involved in terms of data download and power used to run your device etc. My personal opinion as far as learning is that When you put effort - time and money you usually learn better.

Appropriateness of information. There is too much of material that might not be applicable globally. While I can not think of something in the college learning, I recall buying a book for my toddler son. Guess it was on learning manners or something equivalent, and when I was on the page that spoke about manners on the road, it said “always walk on the right side of the road”. Well it was a right statement expect that it was correct for the countries that drive on the right side of the road and not on the left like what we do in India. I immediately discarded the book. But the learning from this is “use local material” to (TL)ea(cr)(hn)ing.

My own vote is for classroom teaching (I do miss the chalk dust; the screeching noise of the chalk on the blackboard). The aspect of group learning is much much different than learning in silos. The questions being answered almost immediately versus the need to search for answers when you take an online course are some of the reason.

Learning for marks or certification is probably “just sufficient” learning so that you get the certificate or pass the exam. But the real learning will only happen when there is no pressure of marks or a need to get a certificate.


Happy Teachers Day.

Sunday, July 06, 2014

What is in a name? Number?


When we wanted to name our son, we did a Cntrl C Cntrl V (Cut-Paste) from our names and made up a name and thought that we had come out with a brilliant idea. The Cut-Paste worked well for us to get to a name that was (a) very simple, (b) easy to spell, with just five alphabets. No surname just the name. By the way we did get his passport also with just his name!
SUnilnaMITa

It is another thing that it was not very visible that our names was hidden in our son's name so we had to tell people we knew specifically how we had named our son. While some said we were lazy, some others took a cue and tried to name their new born the same way. So there were some compliments and there were some jeer. When we told our son about the way he was named, he insisted that he was not sure he liked his name! 
However as far as I was concerned. I was under this illusion that we had done a great job by thinking of a CntrlC-CntrlV name.
This was some twelve years ago.
My tweleve year old son came to me the other day and asked me, 
“Can I please have a personal email account?” 
He insisted that it be a gmail account, not very sure why though.
After a while I figured out that it was not possible to get an email account which just had his “name”. Probably it was taken. While I tried several options and thought that “name.eman” which incidentally was available; was a fantastic idea. But as should be, he was not keen on a 2 times cut-paste name. Finally he chose “name.school_name” as his email. You see he loves his school!
Set me thinking will there be a planned name in which parents will choose their kids name? I my sincere guess is yes. What will the choise depend on? May be the availability of an email address?
Couple of years ago, the name of a child, especially in India, was constrained by several beliefs. A name definitely had to have the 
  • family surname, 
  • the family deity name could not be left out and displease the gods; 
  • well known ancestor's (grandparents) name was deemed good to have, 
  • village name so that people knew where you came from, 
  • profession and 
  • what not
after making space for all these, one included the -real- name by which the kid would be called. 
This method of appeasing all meant the names got pretty long and in a way unique. The upside of this in the age of internet was that it allowed one to obtain a login of your choice on any e-commerce site that you wanted to including an email account! 
However over a period of time the general trend was to shorten ones name. People questioned, why should I carry my profession in my name? Why should I have a deity’s name in a name etc. This ended up making the names shorter which in turn makes it less unique.This was alright before the internet, email, e-commerce were popular. But now with turn in increased e-commerce activity, one needs a unique name to transact.  Else you will need to choose a name with numerals which does not look all that representative of a person!
This set me thinking, will parents now work on a different set of constraints to name their children? Will naming of children be a -new parents- dilemma?  Short or long name?
  • Will it be based on some uniqueness metric? 
  • Will it be based on ones ability to get a decent name space in the digital space (so that one can get a gmail, a facebook account or a twitter handle)[*]? 
  • Will names be auctioned? The ones that can get you a nice email address would cost more?
[*] assuming that people want to use their real names even in their virtual world. 
Or will all of us be reduced to a set of numbers? Like your employee number, your bank account number, your UID/SSN? May be a  universal identification number. The first two digits to signify the nation, the next two to .... and the last x digits represent you.

Atleast kids will not crib that I do not like my name! Or will they say, Wow. My number is a prime? 

Thursday, June 26, 2014

How do I Choose my Undergraduate (Engineering) Project?

Let us face it; all of us as undergraduates have faced the dilemma of what project I should choose as my final year Engineering project.

Recently I was asked this question by a respected faculty of an Engineering College in Mumbai. "Can you please speak to our final year students on how they should go about choosing their final year projects?"

I was not too sure if I knew myself what was a way, leave alone the best way, to choose a project. As I gathered my thoughts, the first thing I figured out is that it was not a synchronous process which could be put as a sequence of slides.

Here are my (not so comprehensive) thoughts in a picture :-)


 Am sure there is a bias towards the work that I do, however this picture (created as a MindMap using freeplay on Ubuntu and exported as jpg) should enable a final year engineering student ask the right questions to converge onto a project (s)he would love to do.

Good Luck.

Tuesday, May 06, 2014

Online Trading - Phone is mightier than Web!

"Can you invest in L&T Emerging Business Fund? It is a NFO and the last date is tomorrow" asked me.

I thought it should be a zippy thing to login to my trading portal and click a couple of buttons and it should happen. And I had not bothered to acknowledge the existence of telephone trading. I found that I was wrong; we are not yet done away with the mighty telephone. Read on ...

I login to my trading account portal. After a little navigation I find that there is no option for an NFO under the L&T AMC. I do the next best thing .. start a chat. The chat is slow but finally I conclude that the only way this order can be placed is through telephone. I ask for a number and he chat "append your local area code and dial 3*5*3*6*". Is there a 1800 number I chat back? "No sir this is the only number".

I dial 3*5*3*6*, choose "1" for English option, the first thing it asks me type in a TPIN which I do not have (thought I would only use the Web!). Luckily I trace back on the IVR and get to an agent.

Agent, "Do you have a TPIN. No? I will help you generate one. Tell me your DoB".
Me,"19xx"

I am now in a three cornered conference. Me the agent and the Computer (IVR).

The IVR asks, "Enter your DoB"
The agent enters this for me! (saves my time!)
IVR,"Choose a 4 digit TPIN"
Agent,"I will go offline you can choose a TPIN"
Me,"DTMF, DTMF, DTMF, DTMF"
Agent, "You will have to type in again" (not sure if the agent was listening to my DTMF!)
Me, "DTMF, DTMF, DTMF, DTMF"
Agent, "Now you can tele transact"
Me, "Thanks".

Now the IVR puts me in touch with another agent. Who helps me carry out the transaction. As I wonder how they can confirm that I had actually asked for this transaction ..

Agent,"Please confirm. You requested for blah blah ... Do you confirm"
Me, "I confirm the transaction"
Agent, "Thank you. You transaction number is *****"

End.

This could have been done much better on the Web. Unfortunately, this particular NFO was not listed on the portal of this trading company!
 

Wednesday, April 02, 2014

Datasets

Datasets

Def: A dataset is a collection of data or a dataset consists of all of the information that needs analysis, generally the data is gathered during a survey.
 
You have great idea. You want to conduct some experiments. You collect your own data, test your idea and report results. Most often the data collected locally is small (to suit your experimentation).

You submit your results and then there is a comment from a reviewer saying that  (a) your experiments have not been tested on a large public datasets and (b) you need to compare your results with existing literature.

You can address (b) by implementing the existing algorithms and then running these algorithms on your small dataset. Obviously more work (need to implement an already known algorithm!) without much returns.

Use of publicly available datasets is a a good idea. It addresses both (a) and (b)!
  1. You get to test you idea and experiment on a large public dataset
  2. You can compare your results with existing literature (assuming that they have also reported results on the same dataset)
Here are a list of datasets that can be of use
All said and done, as a user of these datasets one should also strive to create datasets and put them up for public use!

Thursday, March 06, 2014

Digital Commo[n(on)]sense

Scene: Checked into a 5* in Mumbai, India. Want to try out the WiFi. A screen pops-up and asks for room number as the userid and surname as the Password. I try and get, "Invalid room number and Password Combination".

My inference (illlogical) the hotel chaps must have goofed up my surname. I know my room number, I know my Surname!

My Action 

Me: Dial 0
Reception: How can I help you? ...
Me: Looks like there is a cross talk
Reception: No Sir, there is another girl laughing outside.
Me: OK. The WiFi login page .....
Reception: I will connect you to the IT department ...
Me: Hold .......



IT: Sir, you had a problem with WiFi .. can I help you.
Me: Guess my surname has been spelled wrong ...
IT: No Sir.. Please try to login ..
Me: Surname ...
IT: Please try sir, I am looking at the logs ... (creepy!) I will hold on

Me Trying: 636,

IT:Sir, you entered your surname wrong.
Me:What? I know my surname!
IT: You missed the second p the second time, Sir.
Me: Uhmm .. what is my surname!
IT: Spells it out --PP-R-PPU ... you did not type the second P
Me: Stunned.
IT: Please try giving the second P.
Me: Still Stunned. But that is not my name!
IT: Then I can not help you, you should contact the reception "0".
Me: That is what I did!

Me had a hearty laugh :-)

Friday, February 07, 2014

Exam Papers

Exam Papers

 

  1. [2013] International Math Olympiad also called IMO is conducted by SOF. Generally they have a first level qualifier; which allows students to write the second level IMO. This second level Previous Question Papers for VIII (Question Papers) standard might be useful. 
  2. [2013] International Science Olympiad also called NSO is  conducted by SOF. Generally they have a first level qualifier; which allows students to write the second level IMO. This second level Previous Question Papers for VIII (Question Papers) standard might be useful.

A Lesson Hidden in Two Simple Words

Sometimes profound ideas are hidden in the most ordinary places. Recently, while looking at two common English words, I stumbled upon an int...