Showing posts with label research. Show all posts
Showing posts with label research. Show all posts

Friday, October 16, 2026

Indian Patent Filing | Individual |

 Indian Patent Filing.

Can I file a patent by myself. No patent attorney. No, nothing. An Experience.

Logging into IP Portal

As soon as you land on PATENT eFiling page you have two options. Create a (a) Electronic Signature or (b) Digital Signature. I choose Electronic Signature more because of familiarity of using my Aadhar to esign (for example Indian Income Tax Returns)

Q: How to Procure Electronic Signatures?

A: As per the e-Mudhra policy, all e-filing users are requested to use only the e-Mudhra sign-up link provided on the IPINDIA e-filing portals to subscribe to the e-Mudhra e-sign. Users are advised not to register through the general emSigner website, as it may result in subscribing to a plan that is not aligned with the specific requirements of IP India/Patent Office. The sign-up URL is customized and specifically provided by e-Mudhra for e-sign users of various IPINDIA e-filing portals.

Following the URL you go through a process of generating an Elecornic Signature. The cost of the E-signature is 250 + taxes which (as on 2026-Oct) is 295 INR (valid for 1 year or 100 usages). Easy payment through UPI. In the process you need to fill in your Aadhar # and PAN # (do not know why but there is not much choice) and then you need to do a video KYC and read out a pre-defined text (which is displayed on the portal) and record your video. In this process you create a 6-digit PIN and a username. Post that you should see something like this. Though the approval process says 15 minutes. It does not happen in that quick time. 


An email suggesting to login (mobile # and otp) would follow

Your KYC account has been successfully verified.

To complete your activation, please complete the following:

  1. Log in using your username, PIN, and OTP
  2. Review and sign the Subscriber Agreement

Post this you can register on PATENT eFiling page!
You need to choose a 10 char userid and password so that you can login to IP portal.

Point is you have to e-sign ID to login to IP Portal!

Tuesday, September 12, 2023

Authorship or Acknowledgement? Order of Authors!

 {Personal views}

Being in an R&D organization means there are several instances when you have to write (Scientific or Technical Papers) about what you do in peer reviewed conference or journals.Very often, the resulting work is a team effort and as a consequence most papers, written today, have multiple authors. 

Few decades ago, as a research scholar, it was just you and your supervisor as the two sole authors of any output that came out of the PhD exploration. This was indeed true, especially if you were writing a paper based on your ongoing research towards a PhD. In the pre-google days, the trend was to email the second author (usually the supervisor) to ask for a copy of the paper so that you could read the research and hopeful build on it because you knew that the supervisor would be more static in terms of geo coordinates than the scholar.  

However the concept of multiple authors for a research article is seeping into academic research as well. These days labs write papers and not individuals. As a research scholar (pursuing your PhD) you are "contributing" to the work of another research scholar (in the same lab) and s\he is also "contributing" to your work and as a result you are an author in not only your own "own" work but also in the work being done by the other person. To such an extent that, if you are a recruiter, it gets difficult to know who contributed to what in that article. And this ambiguity grows when the lab is of some decent size (more authors per paper; more combinations).

No I am not talking about citations or the number of papers per person or what ever the measure we have to measure the outcome of research work. That is for another day, maybe.

During the course of a PhD,  the general trend was, two authors (the research scholar and the supervisor);  but today most publications have multiple authors working in similar areas belonging to the same lab under the same supervisor!

Authorship or Acknowledgement?

Having always taken pride in the belief that I have made sure that the research work that we do and publish in the lab has authorship based on the actual contribution by the member of the lab and not necessarily due to they being part of the lab. I was in for a shock, when one of my senior colleagues begged to differ saying that there were instances, within the lab, when this was not true. I was in for a pride-check or a shock. I am still trying to figure out what was the instance!

This came up when a request for authorship of research work based on a two or three days experimental effort was made to me and I thought that effort, at best, deserved an acknowledgement and not an authorship in the research work.

I have not looked at authorship or acknowledgment in any formal detail and made most of  my judgement purely based on a notion of "contribution" a person made to the research work being communicated. 

While I thought it was commonsense ... there is plenty of material on authorship, acknowledgement and order of authorship. I quote.




Determining the authorship of a work or the criteria for a person to be on the author list. 

Authorship

[A] According to ICMJE authorship recommendation be based on the following 4 criteria:

  1. Substantial contributions to the conception or design of the work; or the acquisition, analysis, or interpretation of data for the work; AND
  2. Drafting the work or revising it critically for important intellectual content; AND
  3. Final approval of the version to be published; AND
  4. Agreement to be accountable for all aspects of the work in ensuring that questions related to the accuracy or integrity of any part of the work are appropriately investigated and resolved.

note that all the authors need to meet these 4 criteria to claim ownership of the article. Clearly denying #2 and #3 should not be used to disqualify someone from authorship. All individuals who meet the criterion #1 should have the opportunity to participate in the review, drafting, and final approval of the manuscript.

Acknowledgements 

According to ICMJE  contributors who meet fewer than all the 4 criteria for authorship should not be listed as authors, but they should be acknowledged.
 

Examples of activities that alone (without other contributions) do not qualify a contributor for authorship are

  1. acquisition of funding;
  2. general supervision of a research group or general administrative support; and
  3. writing assistance, technical editing, language editing, and proofreading.
Contributions  may be acknowledged individually or together as a group and their contributions should be specified (e.g., "served as scientific advisors," "critically reviewed the study proposal," "collected data," "participated in writing or technical editing of the manuscript").

 
[B] According to Nature 


Each author is expected to have made substantial contributions to the conception or 

  1. substantial contributions to design of the work; or 
  2. substantial contributions to the acquisition, analysis, or 
  3. substantial contributions to interpretation of data; or
  4. substantial contributions to the creation of new software used in the work; or
  5. substantial contributions to drafting the work or substantively revised it

AND to have approved the submitted version (and any substantially modified version that involves the author's contribution to the study);

AND to have agreed both to be personally accountable for the author's own contributions and to ensure that questions related to the accuracy or integrity of any part of the work, even ones in which the author was not personally involved, are appropriately investigated, resolved, and the resolution documented in the literature.

[C] Authorship (in natural sciences) should be limited to those who have contributed substantially to the work according to Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[D] Anyone listed as Author on an ACM manuscript submission must meet all the following criteria:
they have made substantial intellectual contributions to some components of the original work described in the manuscript; and
they have participated in drafting and/or revision of the manuscript and
they are aware the manuscript has been submitted for publication; and
they agree to be held accountable for any issues relating to correctness or integrity of the work.


Other contributors may be acknowledged at the end of the paper, before the bibliography.

While my own judgement was purely based on a notion of "{substantial} contribution" a person made to the research work being communicated. It is not far from what ACM or Nature of National Academy of Science put it more formally! At this point of time another crucial point crops up. What should be the order of authorship, especially if you have a team working on a problem!

Earlier there was no need to say anything specifically about contribution but today because of the increase in the number of authors per paper, we have a new trend "these authors have equal contribution" what ever that means!

This is also a point of discussion!

 Order of Authorship



According to  Editage  

  1. The first author is usually the person who has made the most significant intellectual contribution to the work, in terms designing the study, acquiring and analyzing data from experiments, and writing the manuscript. 
  2. The subsequent authors are usually listed as per their contribution to the research, starting with the one who contributed the most to the least.
  3. The corresponding author is the one who receives all notifications from the journal including manuscript status, reviewers’ comments, and the final decision.  The corresponding author is often the group leader or a senior researcher whose contact address is not likely to change in the near future. 

In order to avoid any authorship dispute, it is a good practice to discuss authorship and the order of authors at the beginning of the project itself, and keep a record of each of the contributors involved throughout the project.

In Mathematics the authors are usually listed in alphabetical order (popularly called Hardy-Littlewood Rule).

In Computer Science in general the principal contributor is the first in the author list. However, the practice of putting the principal investigator last in the author list has increasingly become an accepted standard across most areas in science and engineering.

End Note

Clearly, while there is a reasonably good discussion about who can stake claim to an authorship, who should be acknowledged and what is the order of authorship.  But the description is so "loose" that each team has to use their commonsense judgement to decide how they interpret "contribution". 

The central problem remain in terms of what can be termed as "substantial contribution" which probably can not be quantified precisely!



Some Thoughts!


  1. A junior member of the team who works on the experiments (and hopefully analyzes the results too) could be the first author. Most research in this digital era is based on the experiments and analysis of the results anyway!
  2. The PI\supervisor (even, if has contributed significantly to the experimentation idea and details) becomes the second or the third author
  3. Any authors of the paper must have made "substantial intellectual contributions" to some components of the original work described in the manuscript
    1. How do we determine "significant" contribution?
    2. Authors could be strongly encouraged to state their specific contributions before publishing a paper
    3. This can determine the authorship order, else
    4. We can follow the alphabetical listing of authors (as done in Mathematics!)
  4. Should we encourage PI in the author list without specific contributions? Namely, discourage the practice of putting the principal investigator last in the author list has increasingly become an accepted standard across most areas in science and engineering.

Friday, October 22, 2021

Views: Essence, Relevance, Challenges and Effectiveness of Interdisciplinary courses/Research

My views as a panelist on the Essence, Relevance, Challenges and Effectiveness of Interdisciplinary courses/Research 

Oct 22 | 1500-1630 |  Industry Institute Conclave-2021 at NIT Raipur

 

Why Interdisciplinary courses are so Important for any institute?

The fact that there are several departments inside an institute clearly indicates that there is some homogeneity amongst them at some level. 

While on the surface Electrical Engineering might be different from Mechanical or Civil Engineering but they might have some commonality in terms of ways of addressing an engineering problem or trying to solve a problem. May be they look at the problem, pick their arrows from their repositories of knowledge, use a mix of arrows, aim them and deliver the arrow with the right amount of deftness to attack the problem. If you fail, you return back to the repository and try to pick up a more optimal set of arrows and go about attacking the problem – each time the pick of arrows becomes better because you have the outcome of your previous set of arrows and you know what all arrows are in you repository and this is a process.

One could, may be, say that this process is applicable to other non-Engineering fields. It is true. 

So if you look at, from the outside, what is important is what is their in your repository that you can use. A multi-disciplinary option gives you a great variety of arrows as against single discipline courses. In a way institutes are in a unique position to help kids build a variety of arrows in their repository. Instead of each kid picking up arrows from a limited set (very often, every kid has the same set of arrows) what if they were allowed to pick arrows from anywhere and fill their repository? That way institutes would have produced kids each having a different variety of arrows which means they are more unique!

What is in for institutes in this? 

Well they know what arrows work what does not and additionally they know what combination works and what does not. This gives them a chance to equip the kids with better arrows but also might be able to generate new arrows by mutations. I don't need to remind in this pandemic how lethal mutations can be! I think if the objective on a institute is to equip the country with kids who are equipped diversely so that they can go and solve problems, then interdisciplinary courses are mandatory.


Is interdisciplinary education at all going to improve the industry outcomes?

If we equate the industry as a force that is at the forefront of solving problems, then the people who are part of the industry need to be equipped with a knowledge repository that is wide in (a) variety (multi-disciplinary) and (b) also importantly there should be a wider variety of people; people whose repositories are different from each other. 

This variety^2; variety in a repository and variety of repositories gives the industry a better armor to address problems. 

Today most industries are equipped to solve problems that are either known or are a little variant from known problems. But the recent pandemic has though us that we should be equipped to address new problems. 

Especially the problems that we do not know are problems yet!


What Challenges will be faced by an Educational Institution during the implementation of Interdisciplinary courses?

Plenty of challenges! 

But institutes are known to be able to overcome them organically. 

First and the foremost would be to design a large number of inter-disciplinary courses in the true sense of variety; this going to be a challenge because you need to build from ground zero. 

But I think given the current scenario in most institutes kids are restricted with blinds to study from a set of courses – this needs to go first for any statistically significant inter-disciplinary courses to make way! 

The second challenge is in getting the faculty from different disciplines to collaborate – while this might not be true in some forward looking colleges, very often I have found members of one discipline not having the same degree of enthusiasm for another discipline. 

This needs to go. I think if these challenges are addressed this will be a great start.


At what level of education, interdisciplinary education can be pursued?

If you look at the current education system, in India, if not around the globe you will see that until about 15 years of age there are no choices – whether you like it or not you have to study general and social sciences, mathematics. 

Between 15-17 years you get a chance to choose something of your choice, which unfortunately is not a real choice in India because the marks and the societal perceptions determine the specialization you get attached to. And this goes into the choice when you are 18 years to do a 3 to 5 year course. 

What is the best time? 

When the child is too young, since the interests are not expressed or known the choice is often made by the parent and when the kid is old enough to know what she wants to do she does not have any space to move. The jig-saw puzzle is solved! 

I think it might be good to have a multi-disciplinary options when the kids are 15-17 years of age. 

May be have an option to choose any subject, say mathematics, history and economics; why should all of them study the same Mathematics/Biology, Physics, Chemistry or Arts or Economics and Commerce. 

I think this two years could allow one to figure out what they like. Allowing them to choose from a larger option during their 3/5 year course. Ofcouse we should have more multi-disciplinary options in 3/5 year courses. 

This is one option which I think will require a lot of infrastructural changes – you can not have a PQR Arts college or RST Science College which means all academic institutes should be able to teach a multitude of subjects. Which ofcouse is not easy. But then who said things are easy! 

If we need things to happen we need to put an effort. I believe early introduction of multi-disciplinary courses might make learning more enjoyable and less stressful (when you see children outside an exam hall catching up their notes just before they enter the exam hall you know what I mean). 

Another radical view might be, say in case of an Engineering college, to give all the students a degree in Engineering without any specific specialization. Once they come into the college they can take any course of their liking in any department enabling a student to graduate with subjects which might include Solid Mechanics, Signal Processing, Computer Architecture, Biomedical … it could be a harsh mix of different subjects. They may not seem aligned but then there might be solution to problems in these chaos of subjects. 

May be this concatenation of subjects might germinate ideas that can solve a problem that we do not yet know exists!


How Interdisciplinary education/research can solve the Challenges of Industry-Institute Collaboration?

I am not very sure of the challenges. 

Sometime I feel this discord is more to indulge in a discussion between the institute and industry ;-) 

If you look from the perspective of students transitioning into industry … Industry always wants a super kid which they know our education system can not produce! 

But I think from an industry perspective, a multi-disciplinary institute is a great place to seek solutions because there are experts from multiple disciplines under one roof. 

But the problem is most institutes different specializations work in a very islandish manner. 

They seldom seem to have the time to interact and do some work jointly; for example we do not find many workshops or conferences say hosted by Electrical and Civil Engineering together. 

So the best way forward is for the departments in the institute be more collaborative. May be one can start off with joint student projects, joint seminars, workshops, what ever. Once this is demonstrated the collaboration with industry will be much simpler. 

Mind you, today we are so in our own that the same technique or algorithm is known by a different name! As an example, edit distance is popular in the Computer Science stream while dynamic time warping is what Electronics and communication stream calls it. Things like this should disappear.


Monday, December 05, 2016

Should Academia produce Industry Ready Engineering students?

Industry ready Engineering Graduates? 

Should we? Should we not? Can we? 

Often heard (when you speak to a person in the industry) "Today's students are not industry ready". And when one of my senior colleagues posed this question it occurred to me if it was possible at all for academic institutes to produce industry ready student and more importantly is it a good idea to produce students who can be absorbed by an industry.

The resulting thinking picture.

Understanding the plot!

On the x-axis is the time and on the y-axis is the expertise. A student when he finishes 10th standard has some expertise which is lower than when he has finished 12th standard (see the plot to the left of the above image). Clearly the expertise increases with Engineering (marked 1, 2, 3, 4) and the increase in the level of expertise is better during the 3rd and 4th year when one specializes and picks up electives.

As seen, good students have the expected expertise, however bright students (or those who have undergone industrial experience) have more than the desired expertise. These  students expertise is closest to what the industry requires. Independent of how good the student is, the need of the industry is a notch higher. So, there is certainly a gap Δe in expertise between the student who graduates and the expertise that the industry needs. And the Δe is different for different industries. May be for a services industry this is small but for an R&D (pursuing PhD) it might be large. Any may be for some kind of repetitive jobs it is that Δe = 0. 

There is this time duration Δt which is the duration between a studying student and a working professional. This is the time that the industry calls as "training period" the time taken to make a student who has graduated to being in the workforce. Industries are trying to minimize Δt, the shorted the Δt the quicker the student becomes a professional workforce provided the Δe is also small. Now the ΔtΔe (product) combined has to be minmized. Something along the lines of  heisenberg uncertainty, one can not have both of this small together. The crux of making students industry read is minimizing the ΔtΔe.

 The problem is that different industries require different expertise (hence Δe differs). Now the dilemma of an academic institute is what industry should they choose as their benchmark so that they can build the students expertise to that level. 

Suppose they set targets to match with the best employable industry. If the required competency is very high while then a majority of the students will not make it (fail to graduate) but the students who graduate would be industry ready. On the other hand, if they fall in line with an industry which requires lower expertise, then most of the students would be employable but this would result in none of the students being able to take up jobs that require higher expertise because in this event Δe required would be very very high. So the academia needs to choose some expertise level that is midway, which results in some Δe hence making most of the students not industry ready.

Aside of this. The question is should academia cater to the industry? Can they? Should they? My personal opinion is they should not make an attempt. The reason 
  • is the expertsie required in the industries change often (in the extereme case the most employable industry itself might change!) and it would be futile for academia to bet on one industry. 
  • academia should focus on producing students who can take up a professional path that he desires (if the academia latches on to one industry, it would kill the interest of some students who want to do something different)
  • academia need not be a feeder to a particular industry
  • the students need to feel the difference between they studies and their work (if they do not they will get bored in their work)

 Endnote

Making  students industry ready might be possible with careful planning between the academia and the industry, but I think this should be best avoided because such a planning will churn out student who have a smaller professional canvas.  A  wider canvas will come into play when the Δe gap indeed exists, so that students  can professionally grow in any direction that they want to. Or may be create newer professions (startups?). 

A Lesson Hidden in Two Simple Words

Sometimes profound ideas are hidden in the most ordinary places. Recently, while looking at two common English words, I stumbled upon an int...