My views as a panelist on the Essence, Relevance, Challenges and Effectiveness of Interdisciplinary courses/Research
Oct 22 | 1500-1630 | Industry Institute Conclave-2021 at NIT Raipur
Why
Interdisciplinary courses are so Important for any institute?
The
fact that there are several departments inside an institute clearly
indicates that there is some homogeneity amongst them at some level.
While on the surface Electrical Engineering might be different from
Mechanical or Civil Engineering but they might have some commonality
in terms of ways of addressing an engineering problem or trying to
solve a problem. May be they look at the problem, pick their arrows
from their repositories of knowledge, use a mix of arrows, aim them
and deliver the arrow with the right amount of deftness to attack the
problem. If you fail, you return back to the repository and try to
pick up a more optimal set of arrows and go about attacking the
problem – each time the pick of arrows becomes better because you
have the outcome of your previous set of arrows and you know what all
arrows are in you repository and this is a process.
One could, may
be, say that this process is applicable to other non-Engineering
fields. It is true.
So if you look at, from the outside, what is
important is what is their in your repository that you can use. A
multi-disciplinary option gives you a great variety of arrows as
against single discipline courses. In a way institutes are in a
unique position to help kids build a variety of arrows in their
repository. Instead of each kid picking up arrows from a limited set
(very often, every kid has the same set of arrows) what if they were
allowed to pick arrows from anywhere and fill their repository? That
way institutes would have produced kids each having a different
variety of arrows which means they are more unique!
What
is in for institutes in this?
Well they know what arrows work what
does not and additionally they know what combination works and what
does not. This gives them a chance to equip the kids with better
arrows but also might be able to generate new arrows by mutations. I
don't need to remind in this pandemic how lethal mutations can be! I
think if the objective on a institute is to equip the country with
kids who are equipped diversely so that they can go and solve
problems, then interdisciplinary courses are mandatory.
Is
interdisciplinary education at all going to improve the industry
outcomes?
If
we equate the industry as a force that is at the forefront of solving
problems, then the people who are part of the industry need to be
equipped with a knowledge repository that is wide in (a) variety
(multi-disciplinary) and (b) also importantly there should be a wider
variety of people; people whose repositories are different from each
other.
This variety^2; variety in a repository and variety of
repositories gives the industry a better armor to address problems.
Today most industries are equipped to solve problems that are either known
or are a little variant from known problems. But the recent pandemic has
though us that we should be equipped to address new problems.
Especially the problems that we do not know are problems yet!
What
Challenges will be faced by an Educational
Institution during the implementation of Interdisciplinary courses?
Plenty
of challenges!
But institutes are known to be able to overcome them
organically.
First and the foremost would be to
design a large number of inter-disciplinary courses in the true sense
of variety; this going to be a challenge because you need to build
from ground zero.
But I think given the current scenario in most
institutes kids are restricted with blinds to study from a set of
courses – this needs to go first for any statistically significant
inter-disciplinary courses to make way!
The second challenge is in
getting the faculty from different disciplines to collaborate –
while this might not be true in some forward looking colleges, very often I have found
members of one discipline not having the same degree of enthusiasm
for another discipline.
This needs to go. I think if these challenges
are addressed this will be a great start.
At
what level of education, interdisciplinary education can be pursued?
If
you look at the current education system, in India, if not around the
globe you will see that until about 15 years of age there are no
choices – whether you like it or not you have to study general and
social sciences, mathematics.
Between 15-17 years you get a chance to
choose something of your choice, which unfortunately is not a real
choice in India because the marks and the societal perceptions
determine the specialization you get attached to. And this goes into
the choice when you are 18 years to do a 3 to 5 year course.
What is
the best time?
When the child is too young, since the interests are
not expressed or known the choice is often made by the parent and
when the kid is old enough to know what she wants to do she does not
have any space to move. The jig-saw puzzle is solved!
I think it
might be good to have a multi-disciplinary options when the kids are
15-17 years of age.
May be have an option to choose any subject, say
mathematics, history and economics; why should all of them study the
same Mathematics/Biology, Physics, Chemistry or Arts or Economics and
Commerce.
I think this two years could allow one to figure out what
they like. Allowing them to choose from a larger option during their
3/5 year course. Ofcouse we should have more multi-disciplinary
options in 3/5 year courses.
This is one option which I think will
require a lot of infrastructural changes – you can not have a PQR
Arts college or RST Science College which means all academic
institutes should be able to teach a multitude of subjects. Which
ofcouse is not easy. But then who said things are easy!
If we need
things to happen we need to put an effort. I believe early
introduction of multi-disciplinary courses might make learning more
enjoyable and less stressful (when you see children outside an exam
hall catching up their notes just before they enter the exam hall you
know what I mean).
Another radical view might be, say in case of an
Engineering college, to give all the students a degree in Engineering
without any specific specialization. Once they come into the college
they can take any course of their liking in any department enabling a
student to graduate with subjects which might include Solid
Mechanics, Signal Processing, Computer Architecture, Biomedical …
it could be a harsh mix of different subjects. They may not seem
aligned but then there might be solution to problems in these chaos
of subjects.
May be this concatenation of subjects might germinate
ideas that can solve a problem that we do not yet know exists!
How
Interdisciplinary education/research can solve the Challenges of
Industry-Institute Collaboration?
I
am not very sure of the challenges.
Sometime I feel this discord is
more to indulge in a discussion between the institute and industry
;-)
If you look from the perspective of students transitioning into
industry … Industry always wants a super kid which they know our
education system can not produce!
But I think from an industry
perspective, a multi-disciplinary institute is a great place to seek
solutions because there are experts from multiple disciplines under
one roof.
But the problem is most institutes different
specializations work in a very islandish manner.
They seldom seem to
have the time to interact and do some work jointly; for example we do
not find many workshops or conferences say hosted by Electrical and
Civil Engineering together.
So the best way forward is for the
departments in the institute be more collaborative. May be one can
start off with joint student projects, joint seminars, workshops,
what ever. Once this is demonstrated the collaboration with industry
will be much simpler.
Mind you, today we are so in our own that the
same technique or algorithm is known by a different name! As an
example, edit distance is popular in the Computer Science stream
while dynamic time warping is what Electronics and communication
stream calls it. Things like this should disappear.