Showing posts with label conference. Show all posts
Showing posts with label conference. Show all posts

Sunday, January 18, 2026

Valedictory Chief Guest Thoughts ICNTE-2026

Thank you for the kind welcome. I am truly honored and very pleased to be in the midst of this august gathering—both on the stage and in front of me. More importantly, I am delighted to be in front of the young minds present today. I am also thankful to Professor Choudhury, who made my coming here possible through the invitation and the follow‑up communication. Thank you, ma’am.

I have a couple of thoughts I would like to share, simply because of my years of professional experience may offer some perspective. One thing that strikes me is the title of this conference. The fact that it is held every two years and continues to grow indicates the energy and enthusiasm of the organizers. I am sure the conference has seen many leaps in the quality of presentations and in the novelty of the work showcased. While I have only had the opportunity to look at the titles—not the full papers—I can easily imagine that the presentations must have been valuable.

Coming back to the title, it is very apt to say that “International Conference on Nascent Technologies” One thing that stands out about this conference name is its perennial relevance. It will never become outdated. As technology changes, the content of the conference may evolve, but the name will always remain appropriate. In contrast, a name tied to a specific domain—say “knowledge‑based systems”—might become less relevant over the decades. In that sense, this title is beautifully chosen. I congratulate the organizing committee and the advisory committee for selecting such a timeless name.

Let me take the liberty of sharing a few thoughts. 

First, I want to talk about the way we write papers and technical documents. This is common advice I give to my own team of young researchers. When you step into a domain because you have read someone else’s work, it is important to acknowledge that earlier contribution. Giving credit to previous work is not optional. Literature surveys are a part of academic writing, but beyond that, proper citation is essential.

The second point I emphasize with my team is that if you want someone to really read and benefit from your manuscript, you must guide them on what they can do after reading it. A reader should not reach a dead end. They should not walk away thinking, “I know what the authors did, and I know the conclusion, but what next?” You must articulate possible extensions of your work, open questions, or new directions that arise from your study. Think of these as seeds in your paper. Without planting these seeds, there is no way for the literature to grow from what you have contributed. Citation metrics on Google Scholar may be indirectly hinting at this idea.

My third point relates to an analogy: imagine a wagon carrying goods on a railway track. Today, irrespective of the domain we work in, much of our activity touches machine learning and artificial intelligence. AI is embedded in our digital and even physical environments. For example, we hear about AI‑based washing machines. I am not entirely sure what AI they actually use—it may just be a marketing gimmick—but the point is that AI has become ubiquitous.

Now, many of us in India may not have access to the ideal infrastructure. It can feel like batting against Wasim Akram or Kapil Dev with one hand tied behind your back. The world is not always fair, and we have to work within our constraints.

In the analogy, the wagon represents the modeling mechanism—the AI model. The goods it carries represent your domain knowledge or data. The rails represent your computing infrastructure, your internet connectivity, and your processing capabilities. If you have a strong wagon (a good model), you can carry more goods (data). If your rails are smooth (good GPUs and infrastructure), everything moves effortlessly. But getting all three perfectly aligned is rare, and it requires significant investment.

In India, we often have plenty of data—large volumes of it—but our wagons may not always be large enough, and our rails may not always be world‑class. This means domain understanding becomes crucial. You might have to “massage” the data so it fits into the wagon and can move along the rails you have. If you have powerful GPUs, your approach may be different. But the key idea is this: as students, faculty members, and researchers, we must identify what we can control and use that to innovate. Complaining about what we lack—poor rails or small wagons—won’t help. Focus on what you can influence.

From the awards I saw distributed today, it is clear that this conference has been an excellent venue for all of you. One remarkable feature of this event is its inherently multidisciplinary nature. I noticed topics ranging from smart manufacturing and automation to embedded systems, networking, and security. Such multidisciplinary forums enable interaction between people from different departments or sectors. This broadens perspectives and enhances the way we think. I encourage all of you to interact with peers from other areas, because that is one of the best ways for all of us to grow together.

With these comments, I thank the organizers once again for inviting me. I truly enjoyed spending time among you. I wish you all the very best and a happy new year.

Tuesday, September 12, 2023

Authorship or Acknowledgement? Order of Authors!

 {Personal views}

Being in an R&D organization means there are several instances when you have to write (Scientific or Technical Papers) about what you do in peer reviewed conference or journals.Very often, the resulting work is a team effort and as a consequence most papers, written today, have multiple authors. 

Few decades ago, as a research scholar, it was just you and your supervisor as the two sole authors of any output that came out of the PhD exploration. This was indeed true, especially if you were writing a paper based on your ongoing research towards a PhD. In the pre-google days, the trend was to email the second author (usually the supervisor) to ask for a copy of the paper so that you could read the research and hopeful build on it because you knew that the supervisor would be more static in terms of geo coordinates than the scholar.  

However the concept of multiple authors for a research article is seeping into academic research as well. These days labs write papers and not individuals. As a research scholar (pursuing your PhD) you are "contributing" to the work of another research scholar (in the same lab) and s\he is also "contributing" to your work and as a result you are an author in not only your own "own" work but also in the work being done by the other person. To such an extent that, if you are a recruiter, it gets difficult to know who contributed to what in that article. And this ambiguity grows when the lab is of some decent size (more authors per paper; more combinations).

No I am not talking about citations or the number of papers per person or what ever the measure we have to measure the outcome of research work. That is for another day, maybe.

During the course of a PhD,  the general trend was, two authors (the research scholar and the supervisor);  but today most publications have multiple authors working in similar areas belonging to the same lab under the same supervisor!

Authorship or Acknowledgement?

Having always taken pride in the belief that I have made sure that the research work that we do and publish in the lab has authorship based on the actual contribution by the member of the lab and not necessarily due to they being part of the lab. I was in for a shock, when one of my senior colleagues begged to differ saying that there were instances, within the lab, when this was not true. I was in for a pride-check or a shock. I am still trying to figure out what was the instance!

This came up when a request for authorship of research work based on a two or three days experimental effort was made to me and I thought that effort, at best, deserved an acknowledgement and not an authorship in the research work.

I have not looked at authorship or acknowledgment in any formal detail and made most of  my judgement purely based on a notion of "contribution" a person made to the research work being communicated. 

While I thought it was commonsense ... there is plenty of material on authorship, acknowledgement and order of authorship. I quote.




Determining the authorship of a work or the criteria for a person to be on the author list. 

Authorship

[A] According to ICMJE authorship recommendation be based on the following 4 criteria:

  1. Substantial contributions to the conception or design of the work; or the acquisition, analysis, or interpretation of data for the work; AND
  2. Drafting the work or revising it critically for important intellectual content; AND
  3. Final approval of the version to be published; AND
  4. Agreement to be accountable for all aspects of the work in ensuring that questions related to the accuracy or integrity of any part of the work are appropriately investigated and resolved.

note that all the authors need to meet these 4 criteria to claim ownership of the article. Clearly denying #2 and #3 should not be used to disqualify someone from authorship. All individuals who meet the criterion #1 should have the opportunity to participate in the review, drafting, and final approval of the manuscript.

Acknowledgements 

According to ICMJE  contributors who meet fewer than all the 4 criteria for authorship should not be listed as authors, but they should be acknowledged.
 

Examples of activities that alone (without other contributions) do not qualify a contributor for authorship are

  1. acquisition of funding;
  2. general supervision of a research group or general administrative support; and
  3. writing assistance, technical editing, language editing, and proofreading.
Contributions  may be acknowledged individually or together as a group and their contributions should be specified (e.g., "served as scientific advisors," "critically reviewed the study proposal," "collected data," "participated in writing or technical editing of the manuscript").

 
[B] According to Nature 


Each author is expected to have made substantial contributions to the conception or 

  1. substantial contributions to design of the work; or 
  2. substantial contributions to the acquisition, analysis, or 
  3. substantial contributions to interpretation of data; or
  4. substantial contributions to the creation of new software used in the work; or
  5. substantial contributions to drafting the work or substantively revised it

AND to have approved the submitted version (and any substantially modified version that involves the author's contribution to the study);

AND to have agreed both to be personally accountable for the author's own contributions and to ensure that questions related to the accuracy or integrity of any part of the work, even ones in which the author was not personally involved, are appropriately investigated, resolved, and the resolution documented in the literature.

[C] Authorship (in natural sciences) should be limited to those who have contributed substantially to the work according to Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[D] Anyone listed as Author on an ACM manuscript submission must meet all the following criteria:
they have made substantial intellectual contributions to some components of the original work described in the manuscript; and
they have participated in drafting and/or revision of the manuscript and
they are aware the manuscript has been submitted for publication; and
they agree to be held accountable for any issues relating to correctness or integrity of the work.


Other contributors may be acknowledged at the end of the paper, before the bibliography.

While my own judgement was purely based on a notion of "{substantial} contribution" a person made to the research work being communicated. It is not far from what ACM or Nature of National Academy of Science put it more formally! At this point of time another crucial point crops up. What should be the order of authorship, especially if you have a team working on a problem!

Earlier there was no need to say anything specifically about contribution but today because of the increase in the number of authors per paper, we have a new trend "these authors have equal contribution" what ever that means!

This is also a point of discussion!

 Order of Authorship



According to  Editage  

  1. The first author is usually the person who has made the most significant intellectual contribution to the work, in terms designing the study, acquiring and analyzing data from experiments, and writing the manuscript. 
  2. The subsequent authors are usually listed as per their contribution to the research, starting with the one who contributed the most to the least.
  3. The corresponding author is the one who receives all notifications from the journal including manuscript status, reviewers’ comments, and the final decision.  The corresponding author is often the group leader or a senior researcher whose contact address is not likely to change in the near future. 

In order to avoid any authorship dispute, it is a good practice to discuss authorship and the order of authors at the beginning of the project itself, and keep a record of each of the contributors involved throughout the project.

In Mathematics the authors are usually listed in alphabetical order (popularly called Hardy-Littlewood Rule).

In Computer Science in general the principal contributor is the first in the author list. However, the practice of putting the principal investigator last in the author list has increasingly become an accepted standard across most areas in science and engineering.

End Note

Clearly, while there is a reasonably good discussion about who can stake claim to an authorship, who should be acknowledged and what is the order of authorship.  But the description is so "loose" that each team has to use their commonsense judgement to decide how they interpret "contribution". 

The central problem remain in terms of what can be termed as "substantial contribution" which probably can not be quantified precisely!



Some Thoughts!


  1. A junior member of the team who works on the experiments (and hopefully analyzes the results too) could be the first author. Most research in this digital era is based on the experiments and analysis of the results anyway!
  2. The PI\supervisor (even, if has contributed significantly to the experimentation idea and details) becomes the second or the third author
  3. Any authors of the paper must have made "substantial intellectual contributions" to some components of the original work described in the manuscript
    1. How do we determine "significant" contribution?
    2. Authors could be strongly encouraged to state their specific contributions before publishing a paper
    3. This can determine the authorship order, else
    4. We can follow the alphabetical listing of authors (as done in Mathematics!)
  4. Should we encourage PI in the author list without specific contributions? Namely, discourage the practice of putting the principal investigator last in the author list has increasingly become an accepted standard across most areas in science and engineering.

Monday, May 11, 2020

Chairing a Session during a Virtual Conference - Some Adjustments!


"can you hear me",
"can you hear me now",
"your voice is breaking",
"can not see your presentation",
"can all of you who are not presenting mute yourselves",
"looks like he is having network issues",
"may be she should login again"
"network issues"
"server issues"

Several months ago when I was invited to chair one of the two tracks in an International conference, I readily agreed to be the Session Chair because of its relevance to the work I do additionally it was on a Saturday and it was a one day conference so a morning flight out of Mumbai and evening into Mumbai from Delhi so it suited me and was not going to interfere with my work work!

Then the entire world was more or less on its knees with extensive travel restrictions and stay at home directives. So the physical conference turned virtual. So now I was to chair a virtual session!

Google Meet was the virtual venue which I was using for the first time, so the best way to take help! was from my son who has been attending all his Engineering lectures on this same platform and I thought is a pro!

The virtual conference was a mixed feeling. Here are a couple of things that will help physicalize the virtual conference!

Sitting in the privacy of my home and chairing the conference did look odd .. so to get one level closer to the physical, I dressed formally (to the pleasant surprise of my family). This definitely gives one a formal feeling of attending a conference (in my case chairing!).
[Dress Formal; even though it sounds odd!]

Invariably the sessions stretch - there is a constant "can you hear me", "can you hear me now", "your voice is breaking", "can not see your presentation", "can all of you who are not presenting mute yourselves", "looks like he is having network issues", "may be he should login again", and a 15 minute presentation stretches by as many as 5 minutes. So as a session chair, be prepared to budget quite a bit of extra time.
[Budget 20% extra time; if all goes well you would have helped everyone slightly lessen the pain of staring at the screen!]

A formal conference lunch time is not sufficient - there is no ready-made food. So increase the lunch time break. Also staring at the screen requires some rest for your eyes. 90 minutes a good lunch break. Also introduce flex you joints break every hour
[Increase the lunch time break]

Do not feel shy to speak out during the presentation if the person is taking a lot of time introducing his topic. A strict reminder to wrap up is a good idea.
[Time strictness in virtual world]

Ask the presenters to email their presentation before the start of the conference. If they can not present but can talk on the audio, you can at the least run through the slides. Even better ask them to video record their presentations. You make sure they have stuck to their allotted time plus you have the luxury of playing the video just in case the presenter goes off line!
[Backup presentation | email | video presentation]

You do miss a couple of things ...

Missing a group photo opportunity.
Missing the reverberation, odor, the coldness of a conference room
Missing the face to face talk with your host
Missing the local cuisine at the venue
Missing the informal discussion with young researchers

Tuesday, November 15, 2016

Physical Technical Conferences - Are they relevant today?

Year after year you get the call for papers (CfP) emailed to you asking you to submit a paper which is sufficiently novel and which has not been published elsewhere. The "good conferences" get loads of submission, they go through a stringent process of review and the the committee sends out accepts and rejects. The registration of accepted paper, the travel and stay arrangements and finally the travel to the conference, presenting the paper (oral or poster), listening to the other researchers or keynote speakers and then back to work. This is an annual ritual, and if you are regular to a couple of conferences, then this turns out to be happening several times a year.

Invariably the conferences are held in "tourist cities" and in most cases the most expensive venues (read hotels), giving one more (only?) reason to attend the conference. Rightfully, you see that the attendance is generally sparse (compared to the the number of people registered for the conference - not hard to guess) and in several cases the only audience in a session are the folks who have to present their papers. And in extreme cases you also see the presenters of a session move out as soon as they finish their presentation. Again because of the venue of the conference which allows them to explore the place.

Now the question is are conferences relevant today? Or more importantly, why were conferences held in the first place. Without looking into the history of conferences, one can guess that it made sense several decades ago when people of the same expertise met once or twice a year and shared their findings with each other. There was a certain degree of anticipation as to what the other groups were doing and probably this was the only source of "new things happening in my field". And it was the only place you could actually meet and speak to folks who had worked in your field of expertise especially if you are a young researcher who has just started out in this field.

Today, when the work you do is instantly visible through your web page, arxiv there is no real newness in what you get to hear at a physical (people gathering) conference. Also there are so many conferences being held in ones area of expertise that there is a good chance of not being able to meet up a good segment of people in your area of expertise. Also most of these papers are available online and in many cases the presentation is recorded and published. Which makes the physical conference virtually available any time that you wished to visit or see or hear.

Personally I believe physical conferences have lost their charm. You rarely see the biggie’s in your area of expertise stay for the full duration of the conference, even if they did they would be tempted to tour the venue! Also there is a small chance of a young researcher and an expert being in the same hotel (mostly the venues are very expensive!) so that they can catchup informally during breakfast! Your interaction is often with people whom you have known or have worked with or .. but very rarely with a newbie or a young researcher. I have not seen many senior (thanks to their experience) folks making attempt to speak to the younger ones.

Today's conferences seem to be an occasion for  a researcher to present his | her work (irrespective of the audience), look around the venue, catch up with -old- friends. This is not a place for new learning (not complaining, we already know what is cooking with most groups through the digital stream - text, audio, video). Summing it up, does not look like a great loss if you missed out or did not attend a technical physical conference.

So why do people attend? I guess it might be more to do with the "number of papers published" which is one of the criteria to judge how well you did in your work plus the fact that most conferences insist that "you must present the paper" to be able to make your work visible (implies your "n" publications become "n+1"). 

And why do organizers organize conferences? (May be not all of them) Because they make monies! A registration fee of "X" attended by "Y" people means an inflow of "XY" monies and a sponsorship of "S" monies. The spend, for a "k" day conference you pay "Z" monies to the venue; you probably give away "p" monies worth goodies to the "Y" people; you sponsor "n" people (read keynote addressing folks) to fly ("W") in and stay for a day ("U") at the venue. Which means a cost of "n(W+U)". Say goodies to the "l" volunteers worth "V" means a spend of "lV". Other incidental charges "Q" which could include the salary for the secretaries. 

So the spend is  {Q + lV+ n(W+U) + kZ + pY} as against a inflow of XY+S. Am sure the inflow is  much larger than the outflow making conference organization   worthwhile.

In a nutshell, conferences seem to loose out in the digital fast moving space and the only reason they seem to exist is because someone is willing to organize it for an earning and someone needs to attend because there is a count on the number of publication.

My personal (short sighted!) view. No I have nothing against the conferences, it is just that they seems to have lost their relevance. With more and more conferences coming up it only seems to aid my personal view!

Sunday, August 09, 2015

God Lives in Argentina

Does God Live in Argentina?

An accepted paper in the IJCAI 2015 workshop meant one of us had to travel to Buenos Aires to present our paper. Because of the circumstances it was decided that I would travel to present our paper which spoke of a bio-inspired approach to correct the speech recognition output.

The first impression you get when you scan of BA on the web is that of an unsafe place with loads of information about where to use the ATM, worry about counterfeit notes, leeching taxis, variable currency conversion rates. Add to this the travel.

Mumbai to Buenos Aires is equivalent to almost 21 hours of -actual- plane travel. A short leg from Mumbai to Doha (3.5 hours), a long stretch from Doha to Buenos Aires (17.5 hours) with a short breather at Sao Paulo to stretch your legs. This is a journey that seems less enjoyable and more of a punishment if you traveled economy!

Reached BA around 830 pm and hunted for a place where I could convert my USD into Peso. I quickly figured out that English in not a language that the locals speak and I do not speak an iota of Spanish. My ability to communicate is tested, for the next 7 days.

I land up in an expedia.co.in booked hotel poorer by 450 Peso. Check-in Spanish-English and lo it is winter in July. Yes, BA is in the southern hemisphere. I looked up weather and I am made to believe that it will rain on my third and fourth day of stay in BA.

Being used to “predict rain” and no actual rain and vice-versa in Mumbai, my common sense tells me that I should keep an umbrella handy. I am ready.I look up the hourly weather prediction and find that the it will start raining from 6 am till about 1 pm and then there is sun shine. I tell myself, lets us. I wake up at around 630 and I find it raining. Wow. This is neat prediction. So I go about the day with my umbrella which means a walk of 1.5 km from my hotel Carsson on VanMonte Road to the conference venue – Sherton. And during the lunch break (around 110 pm) I sneak out and find that it is bright and sunny. Wow again.

And the correctness of the hourly prediction was to the hour throughout my stay in Buenos Aires. Making me believe God lives in Argentina. Na. God lives in Buenos Aires.

A Lesson Hidden in Two Simple Words

Sometimes profound ideas are hidden in the most ordinary places. Recently, while looking at two common English words, I stumbled upon an int...